The public story of a Facebook photograph
Par Gaby David, samedi 19 janvier 2008 à 11:03 (2646, permalink, rss co) :: En images - Comptes rendus
Not really liking my former Facebook portrait photo, I decide to post another shot. This new one is softer, with a view of the back of my nude torso submerged in an orange grainy light. My face is recognizable and my expression reflects an intimate moment snapshot. Subtly hot in content and warm in colour, you see one of my nude shoulders – no more, no less. The left open eye entices the viewer in an accomplice-like smile. A black rectangle in the background, hors champ, is suggestive of an invitation to another space.
To be honest, I did not reflect on this change in advance… I just did it. Then, due to the repercussion the change induced, I decided to analyse what had happened – similar to how any researcher would analyse facts in an empirical experience.
I received comments from my friends and some invitations from people I do not know. Pokes, no, no pokes nor any other of the new “X Me” applications at all. The personal mails were from friends I already had in my list and were only written by my female friends. Did they feel embarrassed or intimidated by the photo? No, I believe they were just winks and smiles of complicity. Men’s auto censorship? Usually we, women are supposed to post non committed photos, “beware of web-harassments, watch out”… The photograph I chose is possibly the opposite of what most women post. Generalizing, when women change their portrait pic it is for one where you can hardly see their face and body, something kind of “I wanna be mysterious”.
Ok, yes, I admit, the “requests to be friends” I received were strictly males' ones, persons whom I do not know in my “real life” and Ok, yes, I doubted for more than a couple of days… “Should I accept them or not”? Then, I decided to go through my friend’s list, to see if they were my friends' friends. Being that too hard a task, I told myself: it is always like this in friendship, whether you open up to strangers or whether you’ll always have the same friends.
Anyway, another former experience had already taught me that if you erase a FB friend from your list the other person receives no notification such as “Gaby has removed me from her friends list”. Probably it's like that in "real life", no one notifies you either. So in the case they’d got too naughty I could always delete them, with not much of wrongdoing.
But, how can a simple image attract other people’s attention and draw their interest towards it? In this specific case, I guess that maybe it is simply because not many people post pictures where the person’s flesh is readily visible, palpable.
It was really weird to check out what “a” photo can or cannot do... & still does...
Every portrait is, in a certain way, an auto portrait because it reflects the beholder’s way of seeing and commenting on it. What would happen if one had to show on the World Wide Web only one photo of him or herself as a self portrait? Which one would they chose? One asks him/herself in silence: who am I? I believe this question underlies my little personal experience.
On both FB and Flickr we can give our opinion on other’s photographs, setting up like this a dialog. In each of these platforms there are some differences between how comments are posted. Here, comments were done through FB in a one-to-one email method, privately, and the rest of my friends could not see them. Currently, I have posted the same photo in Flickr, to see what happens, but for the moment it has not had comments. Probably, it is because in Flickr comments are, unless the photo is posted as private, always public.
“But if every portrait is a mirror, an open mirror, those of us who look at it, we are then a mirror of that portrait, to which we give sense and sensibility… Intimate relationships configurate new identities, where the portrayed, the artist and the viewer, can suddenly be the same person[1].” “If man still wants to see his reflection, if he still wants to admire the grandeur of his mind, he must then take a look in the mirror of the world.” says Joseph de Chesnes[2].
A virtual book with all the faces …is that Facebook? In the last two years much has been said about FB. In my case, I’ve just shared with you what happened. Research should also be fun and learning and understanding how the social web works can also be done through experience.
What will happen next no one knows. It is a work in progress and definitely meant to be continued... so, please be my guest and make a comment...
Tags: blogosphère, Facebook, illustration, photo digitale, portrait


Commentaires
1. Le dimanche 20 janvier 2008 à 15:12, par Marc
2. Le lundi 21 janvier 2008 à 08:34, par Hady Ba
3. Le mardi 22 janvier 2008 à 21:59, par Marc
4. Le mercredi 23 janvier 2008 à 08:00, par Fati.m.a
5. Le mercredi 23 janvier 2008 à 08:05, par Fati.m.a
6. Le mercredi 23 janvier 2008 à 12:26, par André Gunthert
Ajouter un commentaire
Les commentaires pour ce billet sont fermés.